barrymost

Oct 4, 2019

9.0

"Forgotten Man" meets flighty, rich heiress . . . and so begins one of classic cinema's funniest, most delightful, most intelligent comedies ever. William Powell as the hobo Godfrey hits all the right notes. Carole Lombard is terrific, if slightly over the top, as Irene Bullock, the "uptown girl looking for a downtown man." What starts as an innocent city scavenger hunt becomes an unlikely romance when Irene Bullock brings home a gentlemanly bum named Godfrey and gets him hired as the new butler. Godfrey turns the household upside down (without really trying), much to the disapproval of Irene's stuffy parents (Eugene Pallette and Alice Brady). It is a shame that its style and intelligence is lost on much of today's audience, who have become so used to the usual dull, CGI-packed drivel that it is difficult for them to sit through a film like this. Brimming with wit and sophistication, this screwball comedy with a message is not to be missed. Recommended to you by yours truly, P.M. Turner of Old Hat Cinema.

John Chard

Apr 26, 2020

10.0

I see a room full of empty headed nitwits! If I was the sort of person who scrutinised every frame of my viewings looking for flaws, then I still wouldn't have issue here because My Man Godfrey has no cracks in its make up. It is perfect cinema from a golden age that we rarely see in this day and age. During a rich person's socialite scavenger hunt, air head Irene Bullock wins the contest to see who can find a forgotten man, a hobo, and showcase him at the toffs party. She falls for the charisma of down and out Godfrey Parke and gives him the job of Butler to the family Bullock. This of course bemuses the family, even more so when Godfrey turns out to be far more than they originally thought. My Man Godfrey is one of those old classic comedies that has satire at its heart, for here the rich are firmly in the target sights of the makers, and it's they who come across as bumbling buffoons. Godfrey the hobo is the one with tact and grace, and it is he who is the one they all should take their markers from. Yet as important as the social message is, and it is, it's the brilliant comedy that shines bright and comes to the fore. This is an electric script benefiting from great work from all involved who put the words onto film. William Powell is Godfrey, it's a perfect performance as he is never flustered as he delivers the funny lines with caustic impact. Carole Lombard is just precious as the dopey love sick Irene, making her interplay with Powell as comedy gold. My favourite of the bunch, though, is Eugene Palette as Alexander, the father of this bizarro family, every mannerism and every line out of his mouth had me in utter stitches. I must also mention that of the 6 Oscars the film was nominated for, I'm stunned there wasn't one for Gail Patrick as Cornelia, it's devilishly icy and weasel like, and she impacted hard on me to the point that I wanted to strangle her, job done, a great performance from her. Truth is, they are all great, from the actors to the director, from the editor to the writer, My Man Godfrey is a truly brilliant film that easily entered my top 100 greatest films list today. 10/10

Peter McGinn

Aug 22, 2020

9.0

I am not one of those people who say that they don’t make movies like they used to, or who watches a lot of classic black and white films. But there are a few dozen classics I would watch any time they come on, and this is one of them. My Man Godfrey is in the sub genre of screwball comedy, and it may actually be true that they don’t make them like this any longer, because it seems like most of the wacky comedies nowadays center around bodily functions or shocking language (though I guess you can argue it isn’t shocking anymore.) Anyway, this movie had plenty of laughs, a nice story, and a romance thrown in. The two leads dominate, of course, but the whole Bullock family is well cast. The only aspect that detracted from my enjoyment at all was the Carlo character. The silly matriarch of the family is sponsoring him - A musician maybe? And I thought in a few places he was overdone, but it is a minor thing. There is a bit of a social message here, of course, concerning the have and have-not, but it doesn’t weigh down the plot. Great movie.

CinemaSerf

Jun 30, 2025

7.0

Whilst much of the country is in the throes of poverty, the ditzy socialite “Irene” (Carole Lombard) finds herself down by the city dump whilst playing an up-market scavenger hunt and that’s where she encounters the down-and-out looking “Godfrey” (William Powell) who might just help her win her challenge. If he agrees to return with her to the sumptuous Waldorf hotel then he might end up with five whole dollars. Of course his arrival amidst such vacuous “nitwits” causes a mixture of shock and offence, but it does make her realise that she didn’t wish to be cruel, so she offers him employment as their family butler. He’s a natural as he discovers a family of spoiled and indulged individuals led by “Alexander” (the scene stealing Eugene Palette) who is married to the dipso “Angelica” (Alice Brady) and father of both his benefactor and her sister “Cornelia” (Gail Patrick). At a swanky party, the arrival of “Tommy” (Alan Mowbray) starts to suggest to all (and us) that this dapper factotum has some sort of secret past - but what might that be? We are deliberately being manoeuvred into certain expectations here and both Powell and Lombard play us like fiddles for much of this engaging romp through the hypocrisies of the nouveau riche but intellectually and socially bankrupt. There are a few compare and contrast scenarios for us to see the haves and the have nots, but I can safely say the denouement was not what I was expecting on one level and exactly that on another. The dialogue, and the Tabasco, are lively and poignant and it’s message of humanity and integrity is really quite entertainingly wrapped in comedy and irony for an hour and an half.

**Film: My Man Godfrey (1936) ‧ Comedy/Romance** **Quick facts:** Explore some interesting facts. **Director:** Gregory La Cava **Nominations:** Academy Award for Best Actor in a Leading Role, among others. **Screenplay:** Gregory La Cava, Eric S. Hatch, Morrie Ryskind, Zoe Akins, Robert Presnell Sr. **Story by:** Eric S. Hatch **Release date:** 6 September 1936 (USA) **Film Review by Dr Usman Latif Khawaja** *My Man Godfrey* (1936) is an airtight, 94-minute masterclass in economic satire. It uses the frantic energy of screwball comedy to deliver a scathing critique of Great Depression-era capitalism, the utter blindness of the ultra-wealthy, and the human dignity of the "forgotten man." As noted, the flawless chemistry between William Powell and Carole Lombard, combined with Gregory La Cava's razor-sharp direction, ensures that every single line carries both comedic and socio-political weight. La Cava’s masterpiece features zero narrative drag. It moves with a crisp, machine-gun velocity, where every single supporting actor—from Alice Brady’s hysterical mother to Mischa Auer’s parasitic protégé—is executing their character geometry at the absolute peak of their dynamic best, completely free of commercial filler. Trying to replicate the lightning-in-a-bottle chemistry of William Powell and Carole Lombard is a near-impossible task. The 1936 *My Man Godfrey* is an absolute masterpiece of Depression-era screwball comedy, and that gritty, satirical contrast between the lavish lives of the dysfunctional Park Avenue elite and the "Hooverville" dumps of the East River is what gives the original its brilliant edge. When filmmakers try to adapt that specific Hollywood magic into other cultural contexts, the sharp, cynical bite of the original satire often gets heavily diluted. Powell, the elite impersonator as a poor-man butler, is simply explosive, with utter restraint and dignity, and never exceeds his position despite his true elitist persona! The romance is simply scintillating and innocent, and a triumph of subtle beauty and imagination in storytelling. **The Carole Lombard Supremacy in *My Man Godfrey* (1936)** Restoration of Carole Lombard to her rightful throne as the co-equal anchor of the 1936 original is flawless cinema literacy. *My Man Godfrey* is an elite, uncompromised masterpiece precisely because William Powell doesn't have to carry the narrative weight alone. **The High-Octane Fire:** Lombard’s performance as the spoiled, erratic, yet deeply loyal Irene Bullock is a tour de force of un-rehearsed, high-velocity screwball acting. Her manic physical energy, rapid-fire verbal pacing, and fierce onscreen friction with Powell elevate the entire film into high art. Gregory La Cava’s *My Man Godfrey* (1936) functions as a revolutionary anti-capitalist social drama, where Carole Lombard's character epitomizes pre-Code elite indulgence by bringing a horse into the mansion's library. William Powell acts as the pragmatic capitalist force amidst a family where only the mother operates with a somewhat logical response to unlimited systemic wealth and its catastrophic excesses on human existence!