Radical

CinemaSerf

Aug 15, 2024

7.0

"Sergio" (Eugenio Derbez) is a new teacher at a primary school in a run-down Mexican town where his unorthodox teaching methods cause a bit of consternation for the head teacher "Chucho" (Daniel Haddad). There's a curriculum that they are supposed to follow and this school is the very worst in the land. To inspire better results, the teachers are offered bonuses if their pupils can improve, so imagine their chagrin when "Sergio" starts upturning tables and using the school's water reservoir to illustrate the relationship between weight and density. Not only must this teacher galvanise his hitherto indifferent students, but he has to win over his sceptical boss else he's going to end up out of a job! What now ensues is based on a true story and I think could be doing with being shown in classrooms everywhere. Not just because it clearly demonstrates the sheer power an inspirational teacher has to enable young minds, but also to remind kids in better off communities that education (with our without technology) is a thing to be valued. This man offers them a template to teach themselves; to solve problems and develop teamwork skills and to realise that their options are not quite as limited as might have seemed when they started compulsory schooling with precious little interest in any of it. It also asks questions about the rigid nature of repetitive learning and invites us to consider what is or isn't a teacher's place in a community that is historically constrained by perceptions of realism. Can any of these youngsters really aim high and deliver, or is it all pipe dreams? There's a fun dynamic between Derbez and Haddad and the storyline allows us to observe some of the more salient issues that affect these people growing up - poverty, drugs, corruption and family all playing their own decisive part in influencing how education fits into their society. Two hours just flies by, here, and there's plenty of entertainment mingled in with the more serious food for thought. Well worth two hours, I'd say.

Giovanni

Aug 15, 2024

8.0

The most significant revolutions often begin with one individual, eventually leading to a transformation within an entire community. "Radical," inspired by a true story, embodies this journey, enriched by scientific and philosophical insights that bring hope and inspiration to a world that feels bleak and challenging. The film draws parallels to the beloved classic "Dead Poets Society," with Sergio stepping into the role of a modern-day Prof. Keating in a remarkable classroom setting. He dares to challenge conventional teaching methods, offering an alternative approach rooted in curiosity, dialogue, and active participation. As Sergio navigates numerous obstacles, he surpasses his own expectations, though not without facing tragic consequences. This film critiques the current education system, which often produces individuals who function like machines rather than critical thinkers. True learning is a dynamic process filled with discussions, explorations, and a multitude of questions, rather than mere memorization of textbook pages. "Radical" is a source of inspiration, humor, and entertainment, illuminating the path through the darkness of a flawed society.

Radical (2023) Directed by Christopher Zalla William T. Harris, US Commissioner of Education from 1889 to 1906, said, and believed: "Ninety-nine [students] out of a hundred are automata, careful to walk in prescribed paths, careful to follow the prescribed custom. This is not an accident but the result of substantial education." Sadly, though this attitude may have served the purpose of feeding the industrial revolution with unfettered parents to work in sweatshops, this mode of education is still the de facto standard. We are still teaching children to be automata, to follow instructions, to derive answers exactly the way the teacher showed on the blackboard, never mind if you understand the underlying principles well enough to arrive at the correct answer through your own reasoning. I know this personally. I started grad school at Brooklyn Polytech, which was amazing, until it merged with NYU and inherited their professors. My statistics professor was one of "those." He gave me my first master's level B. I brought my final with the supposedly wrong answer that caused the lower grade to him and asked if the answer was correct. He said yes, the answer is correct. (I had derived it from basic theorems.) I asked why, being correct, he didn't change my grade to A. He said because I "didn't do it the exact way he showed in class on the blackboard." That's when I dropped out of grad school. Conformity over comprehension. Obedience over understanding. That's the system that crushes creativity and motivation. Radical is about a teacher who became totally fed up with that system. Based on a true story documented in a 2013 Wired article, the film follows Professor Sergio Juárez (Eugenio Derbez), who teaches in Matamoros, a Mexican border town plagued by poverty, corruption, and cartel violence. His students come to school hungry, traumatized, convinced they have no future. The standard curriculum, designed to produce automata, offers them nothing. Looking for alternatives, Juárez happened upon the work of Sugata Mitra, the educational researcher who demonstrated that children can teach themselves remarkable things when given access to resources and the freedom to explore their own curiosity. Juárez resolved to try this radical approach in his own classroom. And it was wildly successful. The film teeters on the edge of appearing to purposely tug at the heartstrings, and in lesser hands it would collapse into manipulation. But I read the Wired article on which this is based, and the film is pretty faithful to the true story. The true story itself, like the film, is both heartrending and heartwarming. These children really existed. Their poverty and trauma were real. And their transformation, when someone finally believed in their capacity to think rather than merely obey, was real too. All of the children in the film are fantastic and natural. Christopher Zalla did an amazing job here, casting young actors who don't feel like they're performing but simply being. And Eugenio Derbez was as real as it gets, playing Juárez with conviction and warmth, avoiding the moist-eyed sentimentality that could have sunk the role. You believe he cares, you believe he's frustrated, you believe he's willing to risk his career to prove that these kids deserve better than a system designed to break them into compliant slaves. Yes, this is an inspirational teacher drama, and yes, it hits familiar beats. But it earns them. And more importantly, it makes a case that should be made over and over until the system finally listens: education that suppresses creativity, curiosity, and independent thought is not education. It's training for obedience. And children, especially children living in conditions of extreme poverty and violence, deserve much better than that. They deserve to be treated as capable of genius, not automata. Radical won the Festival Favorite Award at Sundance, and it deserved it. This is a film that believes in children, in teachers who refuse to accept failure as inevitable, and in the radical idea that maybe, just maybe, if we stop teaching students to walk in prescribed paths and start letting them think, extraordinary things become possible.